Marketing as ServiceThe Value of Free01/05/09 |
There are a number of service companies out there that are loathe to give away free content, content for which their customers pay big money. This concern is understandable but nonetheless surprising given all that has been written on the value of free (see great Wired Mag article). In my discussion with one client facing this dilemma recently, I offered up a quick story:
Now my client wasn’t exactly bowled over by this story so I started to think of a few other examples of when a mere taste became a tasty marketing dish:
In each of these examples, marketers gave me something of value for free in exchange for my time, my attention, my loyalty and or my word of mouth. This is the very essence of Marketing as Service. Doing something for your customers and prospects is simply more persuasive than saying something about what you’re going to do for them. I’m not saying to give away the store but surely a small taste will open up their mouths and their wallets in a big way. |
Marketing as ServiceEven Holiday Cards Should Cut Through12/24/08 |
Buried in holiday e-greetings, I’m finding myself deleting all but a random few. Why? Because the few that I do bother to click on are either self-serving drivel or simply banal. Like yours, my time is precious. If you are going to send a holiday ecard, make sure it is worthwhile. Better yet, send it in November or January when yours won’t be lost in a sea of sameness. Of course, the same holds true for any kind of marketing. Zig when others zag. And ideally make sure your zig is a service of some kind. If it is, undoubtedly your target will be so grateful they’ll share it with all the friends and look forward to your communications in the months and year’s ahead. Elf Yourself zigged big time and in its third year was sent around a whopping 57 million times. On the odd chance that you didn’t get one, click here to see the one I created starring Pinky. Finally, I did want to share an email I got from NYS Governor Patterson. It just seemed spot on. Happy Holidays to all. D
|
Marketing as ServiceSocial Media as Service12/15/08 |
I visited a client last week who had six copies of David Meerman Scott’s The New Rules of Marketing & PR on his desk. He has made it required reading for his staff so of course, I ordered two copies on Amazon, one for me and one for my staff (okay, so I’m cheap!). When the books arrived, I added it to my growing stack of B2B books I “planned” to read. The truth is that I loath biz books especially ones on marketing. Of the 100 or more I felt compelled to buy, I’ve started half and finished two. Frankly, I get more out of historical fiction and it doesn’t put me to sleep as fast (currently reading The Physician, an epic circa 1000 AD.) But then I got sick and used some of my down time to start Scott’s New Rules. Before I knew it, I was half way through and determined to finish it. While much of it was familiar (after all, we do a lot with social media at Renegade) the book was crammed with fresh case histories and useful links. It was also an ode to the concept of Marketing as Service. Whether reaching out to the press or Twittering, creating podcasts or blog posts, Scott prescribes creating “thoughtful content.” Says Scott:
Or in other words, create something of value by providing genuine utility instead of mere messaging. Scott’s book aggregates a number of cost-effective ways to deliver Marketing as Service with enthusiastic zeal encouraging marketers “to jump in and see what you can do.” Here. Here. |
Marketing as ServiceMaking Friends on Facebook12/10/08 |
Really timely article in Adweek this week on how few brands have done well by developing their own Facebook applications from scratch. Many marketers seem to make the same mistakes so here’s a quick do’s and don’t list: Don’t
Do
Bottom line—Marketers need to thread the needle between what the community wants (fun, utility) and the brand’s goals (sell their wares). |
Drew's ArticlesRenegade on Guerrilla Marketing12/08/08 |
Today’s issue of BRANDWEEK provided a rather scaled back overview of 2008 Guerrilla Marketing which included a short and sweet quote from yours truly. Given the brevity of the article, I thought I’d post my full interview notes. BW: Can you see the current economic downturn as having a direct effect on guerrilla marketing either how it’s done, its frequency of use, or anything else?
BW: Aside from the recession, are there any big trends affecting guerrilla marketing that you’re seeing?
BW: In the age of the iPod, with people so shut off from normal streetawareness, is guerrilla marketing less effective than it used to be? I mean, not too long ago, a pedestrian might be wearing a Walkman, but in general he or she was pretty plugged in to the street landscape. But these days, thanks to digital devices like cell phones and iPods, you can hermetically seal yourself in a world of your choosing, even as you walk around. Does that theoretically render guerrilla marketing less effective?
|
Marketing as ServiceHP Makes Headlines with Tabbloid12/05/08 |
If Joan Rivers were to ask, “Can we talk?” My response might be, “Later Joan, I’m trying to keep up.” The truth is that those of us in “new media” are faced with a Sisyphean challenge, the harder we try to stay informed, the less we can actually get done. Recognizing this challenge, HP has served up Tabbloid that Ed Reilly spotted as a great example of Marketing as Service:
On this strong recommendation, I created my own Tabbloid (see for yourself) from 5 RSS feeds and the first edition was a whopping 25 pages! Hopefully, subsequent issues won’t be so voluminous BUT I can’t help wondering if HP is hoping I’ll print them out on my Officejet Pro K550 which would be good for them but not so good for the trees I consumed. While this is no threat to Google Reader (or other RSS aggregators) especially without the live link functionality Ed suggests, for those who prefer to read their news on paper, Tabbloid may just ink the deal for you. |
Marketing as ServiceWarming up to Marketing as Service12/03/08 |
When advertising no longer talks at you but actually does something for you, then it becomes a service. Samsung places charging stations in airports and road warriors get the fuel they need to carry on the battle. The longer the program runs, the longer everybody wins. Samsung gets meaningful exposure, airports get happier travelers and consumers come to recognize Samsung as a helpful & reliable “mobile” resource. The exchange of value is crystal clear. That’s why I’m only lukewarm about a new program from Kraft as reported by MediaPost:
This is a thin a commitment to Marketing as Service as you will find. Only 10 bus shelters are being heated and only in Chicago. 49 other markets will just see bus shelter ads. So really, this is a insincere stunt that Kraft hopes will inspire lots of PR. And perhaps it will (which may be enough for them.) Imagine for a moment Kraft committed to bus shelters in cold cities the way Samsung has to airport terminals. Commuters would be thanking Kraft by the bus load and telling all their friends how the kind folks from Glenview warmed them up on a frigid morning. Cities would be competing to get the Kraft bus shelter program as a way of encouraging and rewarding the use of public transportation. Okay, maybe I’m dreaming but I’d bet on this approach versus 49 markets worth of bus shelter posters that get the cold shoulder treatment from ad-weary consumers. Marketing as Service has the potential to transform the way consumers interact with and perceive your brand. And to quote one genius at self-promotion, “that’s hot.” |
Marketing as ServiceUPS Delivers Levity11/29/08 |
Service comes in all shapes in sizes. Friday when I called Verizon to tell them that the Blackberry Storm they just sold me had more bugs than entomology section at the Natural History Museum, they couldn’t have been more helpful. As I explained that the camera had a funny way of going on when you were trying to type an email, they listened politely, told me how to send it back and helped reset my old phone. So even though I was disappointed with the equipment, I couldn’t fault Verizon. Their service is simply stellar and assuming I can find a satisfactory phone, I’ll end up renewing my subscription with them. That’s service as service. Before you should even think about Marketing as Service, you better have your service basics in order. One such company is UPS. Their service is consistently excellent, something you used to really appreciate when you had enough money to buy a lot of last minute gifts. But, what’s a smart shipper to do when new gift purchases are expected to be down in the dumps? Duh! Encourage regifting. That’s right, regifting. Send you friends the stuff you never used but for some reason couldn’t part with. Actually, I’m only half joking. UPS has set up a mildly amusing website called UPS Regifter.com that allows you to choose from a series of wonderfully tacky gifts that you can then email to a friend. (Thanks to MediaPost for delivering the head’s up about this one.) I elected to use the Facebook application and sent my assistant a Hawaiian dancer (doll), which she will no doubt appreciate. While the concept is funnier to talk about than it is to play with, I give kudos to UPS for trying to deliver some levity in this otherwise bleak holiday season. And who knows, UPS may actually get some extra shipping biz out of it as people identify some real “regifts” they can pass along. |
Drew's ArticlesIn-Bound from Obama: 10 Ideas for 200911/26/08 |
Stand for Something Capture Your Fan Base In what may be an historic use of email, he reached out to this group before his acceptance speech noting “I’m about to head to Grant Park to talk to everyone gathered there, but I wanted to write to you first.” This legion of supporters was ready for mobilization at a click of a mouse, something that any marketer could find invaluable. While the notion of building a large database of users is not new, the importance of having such a base is compounded in a weak economy since email can be so cost effective at driving sales, word-of-mouth and loyalty. Make it a priority in 2009 to build an army of followers. Empower Your Fan Base The key will be to truly engage your target, inviting them to join a conversation versus peddling your wares. If you do it right, at least 1 in 4 social networkers will gladly download branded content and 1 in 5 will post marketer-related content on their home page. One way or another, be sure to cast your marketing vote for social media in 2009. Turn on the Videos While few brands can hope to gain this kind of following for their videos on YouTube, marketers would be remiss not to create them and use the videos for a variety of purposes from sales presentations to PR, online ads to viral. If you can get you fans to create the videos via user generated content programs, all the better. If not, be sure to keep your production costs low so you have some money to drive “seed” traffic. Lighten Things Up The point of all this is that comedy is still king and, as marketers, we need to keep things light especially in this dark economic period. Even typically serious B2B companies can find a place for humor. Tibco’s hilarious Greg The Architect video series has helped them connect with IT professionals who welcome a break from endless coding and relentlessly boring vendor pitches. Touch Your Target With budgets declining and the “stay at home economy” emerging, marketers might be inclined to rely on advertising and cut back on event/experiential marketing. This would be a mistake. Savvy marketers like Dress Barn have figured out that their customers actually want to get out of their homes and connect with their friends, which explains why Dress Barn’s in-store Very Indulgent Parties are so popular they are struggling to get them all on the calendar in each of their markets. Measure Green, Make Green Expect to hear more about “supply chain environmentalism” which calls for marketers not only to consider what goes into their products but also to track the environmental impact of their entire supply chains. This in turn will create opportunities for companies like Enviance, whose software helps large companies measure and track emissions, and sites like GoodGuide.com, which rates products by their “greenness.” Green-savvy marketers will make the tracking of their environmental initiatives transparent, which will appeal to shareholders, regulators and potential consumers. Do Well by Doing Good A recent PR Week study shows a close relationship between consumer perception and corporate social responsibility—companies that are well known for doing good have stronger word of mouth and more loyal customers. For example, 63% of Americans claim to have purchased a product because of a charitable association with the brand. The key is to pick a non-profit that makes sense for your organization, get employees involved and to make the support meaningful like Home Depot’s commitment to Habitat for Humanity to whom it is donating $30 million for a national green building project called “Partners in Sustainable Building.” Define your Value Few consumer-dependent companies can hope to thrive is this environment, but those with a clear value proposition will do less poorly. Wal-Mart is still seeing modest year-on-year increases, no doubt because of their clear value position. Starbucks, once an affordable luxury, has suddenly become an expensive afterthought. To compete in this dismal economy, your value proposition will be tested like never before as businesses and consumers ask, “Do I really need that?” Spend It if You Got It Category leaders will use this downturn to increase their share and upstart innovators will take advantage of retreating competition. Opportunity abounds for those marketers who classify marketing as an investment for their future, who believe that regardless of the short-term economic obstacles, brands will be built and history will be made. |
Marketing as ServiceChallenging Times11/24/08 |
One thing is for sure, these are challenging times… to find a fresh headline. Here are two I found on pages 9 & 10 in the first section of the WSJ today:
That said, we know business is bad because even Santa’s can’t find work. The WSJ reported on this as a national problem a couple of weeks ago and the New York Post noted “It’s a Lost Clause” in the city as well. So, what’s a savvy marketer to do, scramble for a new approach to reflect the times or stick with a tried and true Marketing as Service experience? I know, I know–my bias is showing. Sue me. Great Marketing as Service programs age nicely and become more cost effective with time. Witness the BankCab which is in its sixth year of driving loyalty to HSBC. So you can imagine my relief when I heard on the radio this morning that the Charmin bathrooms are coming back to Times Square for their third in-stall-ment! P&G is clearly on a roll with this program which reaches thousands in a true time of need. And speaking of third-timers, I’m even more excited to report about ElfYourself 3.0 which is a shoe-in for the viral hall of fame. This JibJab creation, is just the kind of silly service that will bring holiday cheer to all who seek it and will keep Office Max top-of-mind even in these challenging times. Click here to see my silly creation. Hopefully, my bad puns haven’t distracted you from the main point–find a service that your prospects and customers truly appreciate and run with it until you’re certain its time to find a new one. |
MusingsRenegade Spins Off From Dentsu11/21/08 |
As seen today on MediaPost: Renegade, the New York-based digital agency, announced Thursday that it will operate as a newly independent company. Dentsu Holdings USA, Inc. has sold its majority interest in the company to Renegade CEO and Co-founder, Drew Neisser. The deal–a result of the directional evolution of both companies–is both amicable and mutually beneficial, according to the companies. “We believe that being independent will elevate the entrepreneurial spirit that is especially important in this challenging economic environment,” Neisser said. “Without the support of Dentsu over the years, we would not have been able to build the type of organization that we have today. Renegade has always been about helping clients get maximum impact out of limited resources. Being independent will make us that much more resourceful.”–Tanya Irwin |
Marketing as ServiceDog On It11/14/08 |
Since this week has already gone to the dogs, I thought I’d end it by barking about an experiential program that the folks at Alpo cooked up. This program is a unique service (albeit short lived) that Boston dog owners will clearly enjoy. Here’s what the folks at MediaPost said about it:
So what if Alpo marketers are essential COPY DOGs, borrowing the shelter donation component from Pedigree and translating the whole doggie diner concept from Meow Mix? With their sports teams gone to the dogs (how ’bout those Jets winning in OT?), those newly humbled Bostonians need something to lift their spirits and the Alpo Chop House complete with former sports heroes may be just the thing. Woof! |
Marketing for GoodYes We Can - Adopt a Dog11/13/08 |
Pedigree continues to cuddle up to dog lovers, unleashing this opportunistic plea to President-elect Obama as reported by MediaPost:
I give this effort a double paws up, especially as it builds upon what I think is one of the best “purpose-based” marketing campaigns going (see my earlier post on Dogs Rule). So, who thinks the Obama team will heed the call? |
Marketing as ServiceNews to Amuse11/12/08 |
||
Yesterday, I gave a webinar for the PRSA called “9.5 ways to cut through regardless of the economy.” Point number 7 was “keep it light” and refers to the fact, the more gloomy the economic climate, the more marketers need to lighten things up. This is especially true when targeting the under 30 crowd which tends to favor brands that can demonstrate a perverse sense of humor. Virgin Mobile is one of those brands that continues to find fresh ways to engage its target, this time with news to amuse as reported by MediaPost:
Make no mistake about it, this is Marketing as Service for yutes. |
||
MusingsPOTUS is Renegade: Now What?11/12/08 |
Thanks to many of you for the various links noting that President-Elect Obama’s Secret Service codename is–damn straight–nothing other than Renegade! Here’s what they said about it on YahooBuzz:
Former Renegade, Rich Ullman who recognizes opportunity when he sees it, asks “now, what are you going to do with it?” Well, great question, Rich. First, let me assure we are delighted with the Secret Service’s selection and honored to share that name with the President-elect but of course, we will be expecting royalties;-) Second, I am working on my annual predictions letter which will be entitled, The Year of the Renegade and will feature hoops as the annual metaphor. Third, for the moment, there is not third. Any thoughts? I’ve got signed photos of my Obumkin and one unused Obama for President bumper sticker for the best idea out there. While you’re thinking up ideas, here’s a list of secret service names for past president’s. Can you guess who’s who? For the answers, click here. |
Marketing as ServiceMarketing as Zervice11/10/08 |
Zurich Financial is taking a service, or should I say a zervice approach with its recent Z-booths at airports. Here’s what the New York Times reported about it (thanks to Theresa for spotting):
Delivering genuine value to people in a time of need is sure way of making friends for the long haul. I sure hope it zerves them well. |
Marketing as Service |
To be effective, Marketing of Service needs to a genuine commitment versus a one-off stunt. While few marketers will have the perseverance to make it 108 years like Michelin with its peripatetic guides, I suspect they can make it longer than a weekend like the recent painfully misguided “free taxi” effort by Tylenol. Thanks to Jason Wurtzel for spotting these when they first arrived in the city on November 3rd. Not knowing anything about the program at that moment, I neglected to post Jason’s shots (see below) or to feel any sense of flattery since these were another attempt to copy the HSBC BankCab, which I might add is in its sixth year of driving loyalty to The World’s Local Bank. Still on the case, Jason then forwarded this snippet about the cabs on The Gothamist:
One weekend? Is that really supposed to heat up our feelings about Tylenol? As the Renegade behind the BankCab, that just plain hurts. It wasn’t even a cold weekend by November standards so the warming part fell flat. J&J, a usually savvy marketer, should know better than to treat Marketing as Service as a Band-Aid or perhaps they got ripped off by an unlicensed guerrilla practitioner. |
Marketing as Service |
At The CMO Club Summit today, I moderated a discussion among 35+ CMOs about social media. It was really a lively conversation representing the range of experiences of these CMOs. The group divided into three segments, from novices to making their way to “kicking butt and taking names.” David Spark provides a quick overview of the discussion on TheCMOClub site (yes, the very same social network that Renegade helped create!) but I thought add some more detail given the broad interest in the topic. Introduction to Social Media
Social Media Numbers (or why CMO’s should care)
Renegade also created a Social Media IQ test for these CMO’s at CMOquiz.com which may be of interest. |

If you think the marketing challenges of 2009 look daunting, imagine for a moment you were Barack Hussein Obama back in 2007. Being an unknown, untested, awkwardly-named black man with limited resources going against one of the biggest brand names in Democratic politics, you’d hardly anticipate a victory in the playoffs, much less a win in the finals. Yet, that is exactly what happened. Obama’s remarkable success offers a clear and prescient 10-point playbook for marketers who want to beat the odds in 2009.
The Associated Press and Virgin Mobile USA have teamed up to offer two new youth-oriented mobile sites focused on celebrity and unusual news, the companies said Tuesday.








